i have postponed this review for as long as i could, but there’s just no getting around the fact that X-Files 2: I Want to Believe is something of a letdown for me — and that’s after i had drastically lowered my expectations as a result of mostly discouraging feedback about the movie (critics and fans).
according to zarine, a few souls have described this film as something of an “extended X-Files episode.” after watching the film, i had to agree. in fact, if i had to rate it among the best X-Files episodes i’d seen, it won’t even land in the top 10. *sigh*
it’s a pity, really. few other TV series have a more rabid fanbase than X-Files, and although this won’t put me off the series (are you kidding?), i just wish chris carter took a more careful approach while filming this latest offering from his highly successful franchise.
so, what basically turned me off? i can’t put my finger on it really, but i can enumerate a few things that bothered me:
** i know this was dubbed as a ‘low-budget feature’ and X-Files basically has a dark theme, but i wish they had fixed up some of the shots — some scenes were too blurry for comfort, reminiscent of hastily shot low-quality films. that’s not exactly a big issue, but when a film has so many flaws this just magnifies its drawbacks.
** the fact that scully and mulder are no longer active FBI agents practically negates their potency as investigators — i hate to use the term “emasculate” here, but i think this lack of any ‘real’ authority and/or credentials to flesh out their theory sort of dilutes their appeal.
** mulder’s receding hairline, which becomes even more pronounced as soon as he shaves off his beard. and iv’e always though that scully’s hair was dark red (here it’s blond).
** lack of wow factor. i don’t know if this has something to do with the script or directorial style or screenplay, but the film definitely lacks something.
** cast of characters — aside from scully and mulder, and a late appearance by skinner, everyone else fades into background. sometimes it feels like no effort was made to even make these characters come alive. they’re almost like disposable syringes, which is a huge waste really.
there are a few positive things about X-Files 2, mainly due to the undeniable (although a bit lackluster this time) rapport between scully and mulder. their earlier banter was a welcome respite. beyond that, everything’s a blur.
here’s hoping this won’t happen again. (after all, what’s the point of making a movie if it doesn’t even measure up to its regular episodic runs right?)
i’d watch it too — even if it’s the worst film ever made, i’d still watch it because it’s wired into my DNA or something.
i just wish they’d done a better job. as for the early episodes, i’d probably watch them until i’m old and gray (somehow that sounds almost depressing). i’ve also read that link and i agree with most of it, because the author was able to articulate some of the things i’ve felt.
whatever direction the X-Files franchise takes after this, i’m just glad there had been a series where the female lead was able to grow this much and didn’t have to be some blond bimbo or an improbably ass-kicking amazon. scully was neither but she had brains. of course, it didn’t hurt that she looked gorgeous but intellectually she was mulder’s match at least.
Posted by onyxx at August 27, 2008, 12:06 pm
There was a rumor that they’re planning to make a straight-to-DVD alien invasion movie as XF3, but it’s already debunked by Frank Spotnitz in his blog.
I’d still watch that, though. I’m happy enough to rewatch early episodes for now. It’s amazing to see how the dynamics of the M-S relationship developed. Remember the episode (with Jodie Foster’s voice; Scully got a tattoo), wherein Scully was sort of trying “to find herself” because she felt lost in Mulder’s cause? How she grew from playing second fiddle to being an actual half of the team is so refreshing to watch.
Have you read this?
http://www.salon.com/ent/movies/feature/2008/07/24/scully/
I’ve always admired Scully more than Mulder, too.
Posted by zarine at August 26, 2008, 7:32 pm